Category talk:Comics by featured characters: Difference between revisions
TinyPonies (talk | contribs) (Signed comment) |
TinyPonies (talk | contribs) (→Votey-only categories: new section) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
I think we should separate the categories [[:Category:Comics featuring historical figures]] and [[:Category:Comics featuring real people]] by how well-known said people are, but before anyone agrees, I'm not adding any more pages to either category. —[[User:Potentially Wilson|Potentially Wilson]] ([[User talk:Potentially Wilson|talk]]) 16:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT) | I think we should separate the categories [[:Category:Comics featuring historical figures]] and [[:Category:Comics featuring real people]] by how well-known said people are, but before anyone agrees, I'm not adding any more pages to either category. —[[User:Potentially Wilson|Potentially Wilson]] ([[User talk:Potentially Wilson|talk]]) 16:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT) | ||
:I propose that [[:Category:Comics featuring historical figures]] becomes a subcategory of [[:Category:Comics featuring real people]], with comics featuring people who are well-known academically or in popular culture and died before January 1, 2000. So Genghis Khan, Carl Sagan, and Marilyn Monroe, but not Stephen Hawking, Nelson Mandela, or Thomas Henry Selby. [[User:TinyPonies|TinyPonies]] ([[User talk:TinyPonies|talk]]) 17:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT) | :I propose that [[:Category:Comics featuring historical figures]] becomes a subcategory of [[:Category:Comics featuring real people]], with comics featuring people who are well-known academically or in popular culture and died before January 1, 2000. So Genghis Khan, Carl Sagan, and Marilyn Monroe, but not Stephen Hawking, Nelson Mandela, or Thomas Henry Selby. [[User:TinyPonies|TinyPonies]] ([[User talk:TinyPonies|talk]]) 17:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT) | ||
== Votey-only categories == | |||
For Zach and Kelly, there are separate categories for ''comics'' which feature them ([[:Category:Comics featuring Zach Weinersmith|Z]], [[:Category:Comics featuring Kelly Weinersmith|K]]) and ''voteys'' which feature them ([[:Category:Voteys featuring Zach Weinersmith|Z]], [[:Category:Voteys featuring Kelly Weinersmith|K]]), and they are not added to the former unless they appear in the comic separate from the votey. This is because they're featured in a large portion of voteys, but what should be the cutoff for this? | |||
Should their daughter Ada get separate [[:Category:Comics featuring Ada Weinersmith|comic]] and [[:Category:Voteys featuring Ada Weinersmith|votey]] categories? (For the moment, I've chosen to implement that since she frequently appears in the votey.) Should anyone else, like their son Ben? [[User:TinyPonies|TinyPonies]] ([[User talk:TinyPonies|talk]]) 15:58, 18 November 2024 (EST) | |||
Latest revision as of 15:58, 18 November 2024
I think we should separate the categories Category:Comics featuring historical figures and Category:Comics featuring real people by how well-known said people are, but before anyone agrees, I'm not adding any more pages to either category. —Potentially Wilson (talk) 16:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT)
- I propose that Category:Comics featuring historical figures becomes a subcategory of Category:Comics featuring real people, with comics featuring people who are well-known academically or in popular culture and died before January 1, 2000. So Genghis Khan, Carl Sagan, and Marilyn Monroe, but not Stephen Hawking, Nelson Mandela, or Thomas Henry Selby. TinyPonies (talk) 17:42, 31 October 2024 (EDT)
Votey-only categories[edit]
For Zach and Kelly, there are separate categories for comics which feature them (Z, K) and voteys which feature them (Z, K), and they are not added to the former unless they appear in the comic separate from the votey. This is because they're featured in a large portion of voteys, but what should be the cutoff for this?
Should their daughter Ada get separate comic and votey categories? (For the moment, I've chosen to implement that since she frequently appears in the votey.) Should anyone else, like their son Ben? TinyPonies (talk) 15:58, 18 November 2024 (EST)