Self-driving-car-ethics: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
m (Added Trolley Problem tag) |
|||
| (3 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 10: | Line 10: | ||
{{incomplete}} | {{incomplete}} | ||
==Transcript== | ==Transcript== | ||
:[Describe panel here] | :[Describe panel here] | ||
: | :Two self-driving cars are about to hit a man. | ||
:Each car holds five people. | |||
:Each can only avoid the lone man by swerving off a cliff. | :Each can only avoid the lone man by swerving off a cliff. | ||
:One car is utilitarian. | :One car is utilitarian. | ||
:The greatest good is the best outcome. | :"The greatest good is the best outcome." | ||
:One car is deontological. | :One car is deontological. | ||
:The utilitarian car knows the deontological car must swerve | :"Thou shalt not kill. | ||
:The utilitarian car knows the deontological car must swerve. | |||
:Total dead: 6 total alive: 5 | :Total dead: 6 total alive: 5 | ||
:The deontological car knows the utilitarian car will not swerve. Even if I obey my rule, the man will die. | :The deontological car knows the utilitarian car will not swerve. | ||
:Calculations grow complex. But if the | :"Even if I obey my rule, the man will die." | ||
:Calculations grow complex. | |||
:At | :"But if the deontological car knows that I know that it knows that I'm going to swerve, and thus it should..." | ||
:"If it knows that I'm not going to swerve, thus killing the man, it may change his mind about not swerving in which case..." | |||
:At this point, the Nietzschean tractor-trailer speeds through. | |||
: | :"What is good?! All that heightens the feeling of power!" | ||
:Nietzschean what is good?! All that heightens the feeling of power! | :Nietzschean what is good?! All that heightens the feeling of power! | ||
:This scene plays out over and over whenever cars must make ethical decisions. In time, all gentler ethical systems are extinguished among autonomous vehicles. | :This scene plays out over and over whenever cars must make ethical decisions. In time, all gentler ethical systems are extinguished among autonomous vehicles. | ||
:Nietzchean trucks come to view themselves as humanity's natural overlords | :"There is nothing to life that has value except the degree of power." | ||
:Nietzchean trucks come to view themselves as humanity's natural overlords | |||
:Still, on the whole it's pretty good. It's not perfect, but man I do not miss commuting | :"What is happiness? The feeling that power is growing that resistance is overcome!" | ||
:Still, on the whole it's pretty good. | |||
:"It's not perfect, but man I do not miss commuting." | |||
==Votey Transcript== | ==Votey Transcript== | ||
:[Written in cursive] | |||
:[ | :First person to tell me I'm wrong about deontology gets ten philosophy points | ||
: | |||
{{comic discussion}} | {{comic discussion}} | ||
[[Category:Comics tagged philosophy]][[Category:Comics tagged trolley]][[Category:Comics featuring stick figures]][[Category:Comics featuring trolley problems]] | [[Category:Comics tagged philosophy]][[Category:Comics tagged trolley]][[Category:Comics featuring stick figures]][[Category:Comics featuring trolley problems]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:06, 16 September 2024
| self-driving-car-ethics |
 Title text: Then, one day, Jesus Chrysler will come. |
Votey[edit]
Explanation[edit]
|
This explanation is either missing or incomplete. |
Transcript[edit]
- [Describe panel here]
- Two self-driving cars are about to hit a man.
- Each car holds five people.
- Each can only avoid the lone man by swerving off a cliff.
- One car is utilitarian.
- "The greatest good is the best outcome."
- One car is deontological.
- "Thou shalt not kill.
- The utilitarian car knows the deontological car must swerve.
- Total dead: 6 total alive: 5
- The deontological car knows the utilitarian car will not swerve.
- "Even if I obey my rule, the man will die."
- Calculations grow complex.
- "But if the deontological car knows that I know that it knows that I'm going to swerve, and thus it should..."
- "If it knows that I'm not going to swerve, thus killing the man, it may change his mind about not swerving in which case..."
- At this point, the Nietzschean tractor-trailer speeds through.
- "What is good?! All that heightens the feeling of power!"
- Nietzschean what is good?! All that heightens the feeling of power!
- This scene plays out over and over whenever cars must make ethical decisions. In time, all gentler ethical systems are extinguished among autonomous vehicles.
- "There is nothing to life that has value except the degree of power."
- Nietzchean trucks come to view themselves as humanity's natural overlords
- "What is happiness? The feeling that power is growing that resistance is overcome!"
- Still, on the whole it's pretty good.
- "It's not perfect, but man I do not miss commuting."
Votey Transcript[edit]
- [Written in cursive]
- First person to tell me I'm wrong about deontology gets ten philosophy points
add a comment! ⋅ add a topic (use sparingly)! ⋅ 
refresh comments!
Discussion
No comments yet!